POP411.org
Homer News Logo
Search this site



Share this:

Homer, Alaska 2011 Visitors Guide
Homer News Calendar
Story last updated at 9:01 PM on Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Chuitna coal strip mine wrong project for Alaska

Inability to protect watersheds one of many concerns

Dwight Kramer

The Kenai Area Fisherman's Coalition (KAFC), a group composed of scientists and concerned users of the streams, lakes, and open waters of Cook Inlet, opposes development of PacRim Coal's Chuitna coal strip mine project.

Our organization includes 10 fisheries biologists with more than 120 years of experience in all areas of research and management. We have no commercial interest, but we are greatly concerned about the threat to the continued health of Cook Inlet water quality and fish and game habitat posed by the proposed strip mine that PacRim, a Delaware-based corporation, wants to build in the Beluga Coal Fields 45 miles southwest of Anchorage.

The company is in the advanced stages of securing state and federal permits. It holds a lease on 20,571 acres thought to contain an estimated 1 billion metric tons of sub-bituminous coal.

If granted permits, PacRim officials say they could excavate as much as 12 million metric tons of coal annually, enough to fill more than 116,500 railroad coal cars. Roughly speaking, that's equivalent to a train stretching from Anchorage to Juneau and back again.

If PacRim develops the entire lease area -- which is likely once costly infrastructure is installed -- this project could last 50 years or more and would strip more than 30 square miles of important fish and game habitat in Upper Cook Inlet.

Once PacRim strips the coal from the site, it will rely on a 12-mile long conveyor to transport the coal to the shores of Cook Inlet, where a 2-mile-long dock would load cargo vessels destined for Asian markets.

We have serious concerns about the specific impacts this project will likely have on Cook Inlet natural resources, including:

* Strip mining through watersheds: The project site includes a vast expanse of undeveloped wetlands that support healthy populations of fish, wolves, moose, bear and other wildlife. Coursing through it are several active salmon spawning streams that feed the Chuitna River and support Upper Cook Inlet salmon populations. Strip mining and associated development will unravel the unique functions and values of this natural system, and threaten the valuable fish and game resources that rely on them.

* Destroying salmon streams: As currently proposed, this would be the first project in Alaska allowed to mine directly through an active salmon spawning region. As a result, the Chuitna coal strip mine represents a monumental precedent in Alaska. Reclaiming salmon streams in the complex environment found in the Chuitna area would be virtually impossible; in fact, we are not aware of any successful reclamation projects involving salmon stream reconstruction in an environment similar to that found near Beluga and Tyonek

* Polluting water: PacRim's plans also call for dumping an average of 7 million gallons of polluted mine waste and runoff per day into the Chuitna River watershed and Upper Cook Inlet. That's more than 2.5 billion gallons a year directly into salmon habitat. Because the Chuitna River is a relatively low-flow system, it's highly likely these discharges will adversely affect fisheries in the area.

* Risking oil spills: To ship the coal overseas, PacRim will rely on a major coal storage and export facility to support deep-draft vessels destined for Asia. This complex would not only be located in fish migration areas, but also in one of the most unforgiving navigational environments in the United States. As a result, there is a considerable risk of oil spills and other casualties.

* Mercury contamination: Chuitna's coal would be burned in Asian power plants and mercury from those plants would end up back here in Alaska. As many people know, the state of Alaska announced in 2007 -- for the first time ever -- elevated mercury levels in Alaska fish.

We believe the coal strip mine is a poor example of forward-thinking development, and one that will put at great risk sustainable fish populations that already support Cook Inlet's thriving fish-based economy. Outside investors shipping Alaska coal to overseas markets won't serve Alaskans. The expected tax revenues would be small, and because Usibelli Coal Mine now supplies all the coal Alaska burns, none of that coal would contribute to Alaska's energy needs.

Dwight Kramer is chairman of the Kenai Area Fisherman's Coalition. The coalition is a private angler group with nearly 200 members from throughout the Kenai Peninsula and Southcentral Alaska.

We encourage you to add your comments. To prevent spam, comments with links are manually approved during the normal business day. Please be respectful of others with your comments, bear in mind anyone in the community may be reading your comments.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Loading...
Alaska Weather
  • Aviation Weather
  • Marine Weather
  • Alaska Road Cams
  • Road Conditions
  • Local Tides
14
19°
14°
Homer
Monday, 09

Contact Us || Place A Classified Ad || Subscribe ||Archives || Find Alaska Jobs