Alaska Salmon Alliance proposes better way to solve our fish fights

Battles over fish are nothing new to Alaskans. It is part of the state’s story that different user groups fight over who gets what and when. There’s one constant in those fish battles, however: Everybody wants to protect the fish. 

Fish are integral to all Alaskans — they may figure prominently in your household’s livelihood or lifestyle. Even if you’ve never caught a fish, the health of Alaska’s fish runs is interwoven into the health of the state’s environment and its economy. 

All that to say: Fish connect Alaskans — to each other, to the rivers and streams where many of them spawn, to the oceans where they may live most of their lives, to the wild places of this great place we call home.  

Those connections are among the reasons why an effort to ban setnetting in what proponents describe as the “urban” areas of Alaska — including Cook Inlet — is so disturbing.

Instead of bringing Alaskans together to come up with solutions that ensure a strong future for Alaska’s fish runs, the Alaska Fisheries Conservation Alliance wants to point fingers at one group — setnetters — and put them out of business. Never mind the critical question: Do Alaskans really want their world-class fisheries to be managed at the voting booth?

Contrast the Alaska Fisheries Conservation Alliance’s divisive approach with that of the Alaska Salmon Alliance, which believes “Cook Inlet fisheries belong to all fishers and that all user groups should be able to share in the fantastic harvest, recreation, economic, and cultural bounties Cook Inlet salmon provide. … We think it is worth a concerted effort to collaborate, initiate inclusive conversation between user groups, and address problems (both conservation and social) as a community instead of fighting against one another in our respective factions.”

Amen.

As part of its effort “to find cooperation and consensus in the fishing community,” the Alaska Salmon Alliance is hosting an open house event in Homer from 6-8:30 p.m. Nov. 22 at the Elks Lodge. 

Among the topics up for discussion is the ballot initiative, but organizers warn this event “will not be business as usual.”

“We aren’t interested in rehashing old prejudices or assigning blame. This is an opportunity for fishermen to participate and shape a new dialogue, meet other like-minded folks, and move away from this fight everyone is tired of having,” said Hannah Harrison, the group’s community outreach and education specialist, in a press release.

The event is designed to be a “neutral atmosphere where fishermen are going to be asked to identify problems in the fishery and come up with new approaches to thinking about them and solving them,” she said.

The approach of the Alaska Salmon Alliance deserves applause and support. 

Alaska’s wild fish runs should not be used to divide Alaskans; instead, the protection of these wonderful resources should bring all Alaskans together in search of solutions that keep all of our fisheries healthy for future generations. Southern Kenai Peninsula fishermen — all user groups and gear types — would do well to take a leading role in this discussion.

More in News

Surgeon general tours Dena’ina Wellness Center as part of statewide tour

The federal official tasked with providing health advice to the nation last… Continue reading

Kachemak Bay Campus Director Carol Swartz, left, speaks June 8, 2018, at the opening of the 2018 Kachemak Bay Writers’ Conference at Land’s End Resort in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Kachemak Bay Campus director set to retire

Carol Swartz, director of Kachemak Bay Campus, will retire from the University… Continue reading

A spawning chum salmon looks to return to the waters of Salmon Creek on Tuesday, July 24, 2018. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire)
Supreme Court approves Stand for Salmon ballot initiative

The Alaska Supreme Court on Wednesday approved the Stand for Salmon ballot initiative for this fall’s elections, but not before deleting some provisions that violate the Alaska Constitution.

Seabird die-offs may be connected to warming ocean

ANCHORAGE — Federal wildlife officials are documenting a die-off of Alaska seabirds… Continue reading

Dorothy Drive easement petition pulled

Dorothy Drive landowners pulled their petition to vacate the last 2,000 feet… Continue reading

State agency seizes political campaign signs in Anchorage

ANCHORAGE (AP) — The Alaska Department of Transportation seized several political campaign… Continue reading

Cox takes second run for District 31 rep

In a second run at the Republican Party nomination for the Alaska… Continue reading

Henry “Hank” Kroll, candidate for the Republican Party nomination, District 31 Representative. (Photo provided)
Kroll: Lifelong Alaskan brings sourdough perspective to race

If the mold got broken making a classic Republican Alaska politician like… Continue reading

Most Read