Council needs to fix condo assessments, move to other things

  • Wednesday, April 15, 2015 4:34pm
  • News

While the Homer City Council’s desire to be “uniform and fair” when it comes to assessments for natural gas is admirable, that desire begs the question: Fair to whom?

More than a year ago, Jan. 6, 2014, Kenai Superior Court Judge Charles Huguelet ruled that the way the city chose to assess condominiums for natural gas was not fair. He called it “arbitrary and unreasonable.”

The city chose not to appeal that decision. Now, all these months later, the council is asking for a Supreme Court review of Huguelet’s ruling that the city stop using its preferred method for assessing condo owners in the Homer’s natural gas special assessment district.

Why? Why now?

One of the clear messages that came out of the discussions on how best to assess for natural gas was: There is no one way that will please everyone. Every scenario had pluses and minuses. In each, there were some citizens who could claim being treated unfairly.

If the council wants to talk fairness, what about these issues: Is it fair that a big business pay the same assessment as a mom-and-pop store? Is it fair that those with little income and small houses pay the same as those with lots of money and huge houses? Is it fair that no matter what the city does, some people will not be able to afford the changeover to natural gas, but still have to pay the assessment?

But “fairness” really isn’t the point. Didn’t council members learn in kindergarten life isn’t fair and sometimes doing the right thing has the appearance of being unfair?

Homer condominium owners have both rightness and the law on their side. Huguelet’s ruling does not make them a “preferred class of property owners who will pay less than other property owners,” as Mayor Pro Tempore Francie Roberts read in a statement Monday night. It just gives them their rights under established condominium law. As Huguelet noted in his original decision, “There is no logical nexus between the charge to plaintiff and the benefit of having access to the natural gas line. Other lots with multiple habitable units were give the same access to the natural gas line and only charged one fee.” 

A condo building receives the same benefit as an apartment building — access to gas service from a distribution line running by a lot. 

Most Homer residents understand this. Condo owners should not be blamed if their property rights interfere with the council’s preferred method of assessing for natural gas. And the council should not try to pit other residents against the condominium owners. We all need to stand up for each other.

Bringing natural gas to Homer was beneficial for the community. Arguing about assessments for condominiums is not. The council’s refusal to accept Judge Huguelet’s order — especially when the city chose not to appeal the ruling within the designated timeframe — makes council members look obstinate and more than a little like they’re unwilling to follow the rules if those rules don’t agree with them.

The council can be proud of its work to get natural gas to Homer. Such a big project isn’t going to be without challenges — like how best to assess everyone. 

In this case, the assessment method decided on is not only unfair to condo owners, it’s unlawful. The council and city need to recognize that and move forward to right that wrong.


More in News

American flags fly on Sept. 11, 2020, in the park at the corner of Lake Street and the Homer Bypass Road in Homer, Alaska. Rotary Club of Homer Downtown places the flags every year to honor the people killed and injured in the events of Sept. 11, 2001. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Remembering Sept. 11

Robert Purcell shares memories of the aftermath of 9/11 20 years later.

Homer High School. (Homer News file photo)
School announcements

School district risk level update and upcoming events

Visitors explore shops on the Homer Spit before the upcoming end of the season. (Photo by Sarah Knapp/Homer News)
Successful tourist season leaves businesses in need of rest

Many shops on the Spit close down after Labor Day.

A sign advertises free COVID-19 vaccines at the Ted Stevens Anchorage International Airport on July 13, 2021, in Anchorage, Alaska. The state announced a new initiative that gives newly vaccinated Alaskans an opportunity to win $49,000. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Newly vaccinated get chance to win cash

Incentive campaign to grant $49,000 cash and scholarship prizes to weekly winners

A sign flashing "Keep COVID down" also offers information on where to get testing and vaccines on Thursday, Sept. 2, 2021, on the Homer Spit in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Homer schools go to universal masking

Increase in COVID-19 cases prompts Homer schools to require universal masking until at least Sept. 21.

A sign in front of Kenai Middle School is seen on Sept. 2, 2021, in Kenai, Alaska. The school was one of more than a dozen Kenai Peninsula Borough School District schools operating with universal indoor masking due to rising COVID-19 cases. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
More schools go to universal indoor masking

More than 200 students have tested positive for COVID-19 since Aug. 23.

Most Read