Putting transfer site in private hands raises more questions than answers

  • By Dale Banks
  • Wednesday, April 24, 2013 5:29pm
  • News

Dale Banks

Garbage is a dirty business. Homer’s new transfer site, a $12 million or so project, has been privatized and will soon be operated by the lowest bidder.

I had been waiting to see the proposal for privatization to come forward as an ordinance on the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly agenda so that I could testify to the assembly, since I have a few things to say on the matter. But, lo and behold, the mayor decided that it was not necessary to have any public hearing on this type of privatization action and moved forward administratively with soliciting bids for the operation of the transfer site and hauling of the waste to Soldotna.

Hauling around Homer has been done successfully by private operators for a long time, but the operations at the Homer site have always been a borough responsibility. According to a quote from the mayor, this privatization will save the borough $250,000 per year. That’s about $5 per person in the borough. I’m sure we’re all happy to save $5 a year, but how does one go about saving $250,000 in a year out of a major operation budget and still have a contractor making a profit?

My guess is that the formula will include lower wages, lower, if any, benefits, and a reduced number of staff at the site. I can’t help but think that this will lead to a lower level of service. How much of that $250,000 “savings” will be at the expense of local jobs? How will this loss of good jobs in turn affect the local economy? How will the privatization affect possibilities for potential future changes at the transfer site such as composting?

There is currently an ongoing borough-funded feasibility study looking at municipal composting. It’s due to be completed soon, but with a privatized operation it seems less likely that composting would move forward here even if recommended by the study. Will the private contractors promote recycling since there is no direct benefit either way for them? What long term considerations such as maintenance and repairs on the facility are factored in to the “savings”? How could a real number for savings even be arrived at without any baseline history about how much it will cost to operate the new facility effectively? It seems like the borough would need to operate it for a year to determine actual costs for comparison. Is the cost of monitoring and oversight of the contractor included in this accounting?

I don’t know the answers to these questions since there was no meaningful public discussion or presentation of the issue, or any of these details. I am disappointed in the mayor for moving privatization forward without bringing it out first as an ordinance to the assembly, or at least having a hearing in Homer to gauge the local preference.

I am concerned that Homer will be left with a lower level of service than we are accustomed to, will have less potential for progressive waste management solutions, and will take an economic and social hit as a result of this action.

If indeed these are the costs of the “savings” from privatization, then I would gladly give my $5 back. The proposal to privatize operations at an important and integral community facility should have been brought before the community to be affected. Instead, it has been dumped on us.

Dale Banks owns Loopy Lupine Distribution, a manufacturer of compostable paper coffee cups and wholesale distributor of food service, janitorial and business paper supplies. He sorts his waste and has lived in the greater service area of the Homer landfill for 20 years or so.




More in News

Dollynda Phelps discusses current issues in the cannabis industry with local business owners on Wednesday, Sept. 12, 2018, in Kenai, Alaska. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)
Cannabis industry meeting raises concerns over Alcohol and Marijuana Control Office

Cannabis cultivators, retailers and consumers squeezed into a small Kenai living room… Continue reading

The wall of the Red Chris tailings pond is a little less than 350 feet, or about the height of a 35-story building. It follows the same design as the Mount Polley tailings dam, which broke in 2014, sending 24 million cubic meters of toxic mine tailings into the Fraser River watershed. It is designed, however, to hold 305 million cubic meters of mine waste — seven times more than Mount Polley. Both mines are owned by Imperial Metals. (Courtesy Photo | Garth Lenz via Salmon State)
Transboundary mine faces $200-million cash crunch

With a strike, falling copper prices and more than $554-million ($723 million… Continue reading

Niko Mogar is shown in a June 2018 booking photo. (Photo provided, Homer Police)
Police arrest Homer area thief on new counts

A man charged last month with burglary and vehicle theft faces new… Continue reading

Homer area residents listen to the Tuesday, Sept. 18, 2018 Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly meeting at Homer City Hall in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Residents talk Kachemak Selo school at assembly

While no major action was taken at Tuesday’s Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly… Continue reading

Ken Castner III answers a question at a city council and mayoral candidate forum Tuesday, Sept. 11, 2018 at Alice’s Champagne Palace in Homer, Alaska. Castner is running for Homer mayor. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Castner running for mayor to promote unity

Although Ken Castner has served on numerous city commissions, committees and task… Continue reading

Homer area school announcements

Homer High School Friday — Homecoming football game against Seward High School… Continue reading

David Lewis, a former member of the Homer City Council, makes his final remarks during his last meeting as a council member Monday, Oct. 9, 2017 in Cowles Council Chambers in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Lewis takes second try at Homer mayor

Veteran Homer City Council member David Lewis will take another run for… Continue reading

Borough elections 2018: What you need to know

In between the August primary election and the November general election, Homer… Continue reading

Supreme Court finds Griswold due process rights violated

The Alaska Supreme Court on Friday found the Kenai Superior Court violated… Continue reading

Most Read