Resetarits hearing continued again; Murphy gives another 30 days

Despite a warning last month that she would need to see progress on a resolution in the case of two Homer brothers charged with second-degree sexual assault in relation to an incident last year at a Homer teen drinking party, Judge Margaret Murphy continued for another 30 days a preliminary hearing for Anthony Resetarits, 21, and Joseph Resetarits, 19. 

The assault, and allegations that others photographed all or part of the incident and that bystanders did not intervene or call 911, shocked Homer when it became public after the arrests of the brothers in October. Alaska State Troopers charged that the brothers committed sexual penetration on the boy, then 17, with an object. The brothers were released on bail shortly after their arrest and have been allowed to leave Homer to fish commercially and also to attend college in the Lower 48.

At the last hearing, Murphy warned defense lawyers and the prosecution that she would need to see some progress by Tuesday’s hearing. Assistant District Attorney Scott Leaders said the state had made a plea agreement offer to defense lawyers last week and that progress had been made.

Murphy grudgingly accepted that progress, but warned both sides this would be the last continuance of a preliminary hearing.

“It’s time to get this case moving,” Murphy said.

Joseph Resetarits’ lawyer, Mike Moberly, said he had received an offer, but that it was “not appealing.” Neither side revealed the terms of the agreement. Moberly said he wanted more time to discuss the offer with his client and to educate him about the ramifications of it. Both brothers attended telephonically from out of state, where they are attending college. That drew a rebuke from Murphy.

“Quite frankly, both of you asked that they be permitted to depart the state,” Murphy said, speaking to Moberly and Lisa Rosano, an assistant to Phillip Weidner, Anthony Resetarits’ lawyer. Both lawyers also attended telephonically. “If being out of state is an impediment, there is a solution to that — come back in state.”

The mother of the victim protested the continuance for another 30 days. She said that she had already lost one job for having to appear in court and her life had been affected by the ongoing stress of court hearings. The boy left Alaska after the incident and now attends college out of state.

“I have to get on with my life,” the mother said. “Another 30 days seems ridiculous.”

Leaders agreed to the 30-day continuance.

“I understand the court’s frustration,” he said. “I understand the court’s instruction. We have made progress.”

Murphy said the defense and prosecution need to reach an agreement or take the charges to a grand jury. Under court rules for felony charges, a preliminary hearing must be held or a grand jury indictment charged within 10 days for a defendant in custody or 20 days for a defendant out of custody. Last week, for example, Murphy dismissed charges against a Homer man, Corey Rosano, charged with sexual abuse of a minor and child pornography because a preliminary hearing was not held within 10 days. Both sides can agree to continued preliminary hearings if a judge consents. 

“I hope this will be the final time for if these parties have an agreement or if these cases will go to trial,” Murphy said.

Murphy set the next hearing for the Resetarits brothers for Oct. 3 at 3:30 p.m. By then it will have almost have been a year since they were arrested.

Michael Armstrong can be reached at

More in News

The 2021 elections will be held Oct. 5.
Kenai Peninsula Borough School Board Q&A

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

The 2021 elections will be held Oct. 5.
Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly Q&A

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

The 2021 elections will be held Oct. 5.
Homer City Council candidate Q&A

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

Traffic moves north along the Sterling Highway shortly after a fatal crash closed the highway for several hours Wednesday, Feb. 24, 2021. The state is seeking federal funding for a project aimed at improving safety along the Sterling Highway between mileposts 82.5 to 94, or between Sterling and Soldotna. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
State looks to federal funding for Sterling Highway project

The project is aimed at improving highway safety between Sterling and Soldotna.

Ethan Benton (left) and Laura Walters of Kodiak win the vaccine lottery for the Alaska Chamber's week one vaccine lottery giveaway "Give AK a Shot." (Screenshot)
State names winners in 1st vaccine lottery

A Valdez and Kodiak resident took home checks for $49,000 each.

Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion
A podium marks the beginning of a StoryWalk at Soldotna Creek Park on Tuesday, June 29, 2021 in Soldotna, Alaska. The project was discontinued in August due to vandalism.
Vandalism ends Soldotna library program

The StoryWalk was made possible by a $2,500 donation from the Soldotna Library Friends.

Juneau Empire file
The Coast Guard medevaced a 90-year-old suffering stroke-like symptoms near Ketchikan aboard a 45-foot response boat-medium like this one, seen in Juneau, on Thursday, Sept. 16, 2021.
Coast Guard medevacs man from yacht near Ketchikan

The 90-year-old suffered symptoms of a stroke.

James Varsos, also known as “Hobo Jim,” poses for a photo during the August 2016, Funny River Festival in Funny River, Alaska, in August 2016. (Peninsula Clarion file)
‘Hobo Jim’ opens up about recent terminal cancer diagnosis

Varsos was named Alaska’s official “state balladeer” in 1994.

Most Read