State withdraws plea agreement in boat arson case

The prosecution withdrew a plea agreement last Wednesday, Aug. 14, in the case of Makai “Mike” Martushoff, 59. Martushoff had been charged with one count of first-degree arson, a class A felony. A change-of-plea hearing scheduled for July 29 had been continued to Aug. 8 and then Aug. 14, but on Wednesday assistant district attorney Kelly Lawson said the state was pulling the offer.

At last week’s hearing, Magistrate George Peck took no action on the plea withdrawal and continued a preliminary hearing to 3:30 p.m. Aug. 23.

Martushoff was charged with allegedly burning a fishing boat in dry dock at the Northern Enterprises Boatyard on Oct. 29, 2012.

Police allege Martushoff intentionally set his father’s boat, the Slava II, on fire in an attempt to kill himself. The boat had major damage, but firefighters kept the fire from spreading to nearby boats. Martushoff suffered burn injuries and was hospitalized. He has either been hospitalized or in jail since then.

At the hearing, Martushoff’s public defender, Hatton Greer, said his client had accepted an offer to plead guilty to a misdemeanor charge of criminally negligent burning. If that deal had been accepted, Martushoff would have had to serve no more than a year in jail. Martushoff was close to having served his time if the deal had been accepted.

In court, Greer said the plea offer and acceptance should be treated as a legal contract. He later clarified in e-mail that he was making an analogy between the deal and a contract. Greer told the magistrate that he objected to the withdrawal of the plea agreement and would be filing a motion to that effect. Peck said he would not decide anything that day.

Martushoff has not yet been indicted for arson by a grand jury. Under court rules, a defendant in custody must either be indicted or a preliminary hearing held within 10 days. Preliminary hearings have been held and continued, and Greer has waived two court rules, Rule 5 and Rule 45. Rule 5 governs when cases must be brought to a grand jury and Rule 45, the “speedy trial” rule, when cases must go to trial.

Greer argued that with the plea agreement made on July 26, now that the deal has been withdrawn, that is when Rule 5 should start to toll — that is, when the 10-day deadline for an indictment starts. Greer requested the arson charge be dismissed because that deadline had passed, but Peck did not rule on that request. Greer also did not waive rule 5. Peck agreed that the 45-day rule should toll from July 26.

Peck did set another preliminary hearing within 10 days of Aug. 14.

In the original complaint, police alleged that Martushoff threatened his father and Michael Hough, the father’s lawyer. The father had filed several civil suits against his son. Police alleged Martushoff threatened to kill his father and Hough and burn down their houses. Hough and the father attended last week’s hearing. Hough had earlier expressed concerns about reducing the charge to a misdemeanor and had a meeting last week with Lawson, he said.

Michael Armstrong can be reached at michael.

More in News

The 2021 elections will be held Oct. 5.
Kenai Peninsula Borough School Board Q&A

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

The 2021 elections will be held Oct. 5.
Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly Q&A

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

The 2021 elections will be held Oct. 5.
Homer City Council candidate Q&A

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

Traffic moves north along the Sterling Highway shortly after a fatal crash closed the highway for several hours Wednesday, Feb. 24, 2021. The state is seeking federal funding for a project aimed at improving safety along the Sterling Highway between mileposts 82.5 to 94, or between Sterling and Soldotna. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
State looks to federal funding for Sterling Highway project

The project is aimed at improving highway safety between Sterling and Soldotna.

Ethan Benton (left) and Laura Walters of Kodiak win the vaccine lottery for the Alaska Chamber's week one vaccine lottery giveaway "Give AK a Shot." (Screenshot)
State names winners in 1st vaccine lottery

A Valdez and Kodiak resident took home checks for $49,000 each.

Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion
A podium marks the beginning of a StoryWalk at Soldotna Creek Park on Tuesday, June 29, 2021 in Soldotna, Alaska. The project was discontinued in August due to vandalism.
Vandalism ends Soldotna library program

The StoryWalk was made possible by a $2,500 donation from the Soldotna Library Friends.

Juneau Empire file
The Coast Guard medevaced a 90-year-old suffering stroke-like symptoms near Ketchikan aboard a 45-foot response boat-medium like this one, seen in Juneau, on Thursday, Sept. 16, 2021.
Coast Guard medevacs man from yacht near Ketchikan

The 90-year-old suffered symptoms of a stroke.

James Varsos, also known as “Hobo Jim,” poses for a photo during the August 2016, Funny River Festival in Funny River, Alaska, in August 2016. (Peninsula Clarion file)
‘Hobo Jim’ opens up about recent terminal cancer diagnosis

Varsos was named Alaska’s official “state balladeer” in 1994.

Most Read