Ariel Silverman (Photo courtesy of Ariel Silverman)

Ariel Silverman (Photo courtesy of Ariel Silverman)

Point of View: Why recycling electronics helps fight Pebble

For the past 15 years, Cook Inletkeeper and its partners have hosted electronics recycling (e-cycling) events around the Kenai Peninsula. As this year’s events fast approach, it’s important to understand the many advantages of recycling electronic waste.

One of the most important benefits to e-recycling is helping to protect the fisheries and communities in the Bristol Bay watershed from the damages that will be generated by the proposed Pebble Mine.

Electronic waste includes products that have become unwanted, non-working or obsolete. Electronic waste often contains toxic substances such as lead, mercury, cadmium, chromium and other heavy metals hazardous to the environment and humans. If these metals are not recycled or properly processed (e.g. dumped at local landfill), toxic chemicals can pollute water supplies and endanger local communities, livestock and wildlife that live nearby.

E-cycling prevents toxic substances from entering the environment and keeps our communities safe. Additionally, recycling electronics supplies a growing market for recycling firms and green jobs. Essentially, e-cycling is one of the many small things we can do to make our communities, economy, and environment more sustainable.

While e-cycling is important for all of the above reasons, by recycling your electronic waste, you are also reducing the need for projects like Pebble Mine.

One of the arguments in support of Pebble Mine is to preserve America’s mineral security. Copper — the predominant mineral which will be extracted from the Bristol Bay Watershed — is a necessary component of electronics and electricity delivery, transportation, building construction, and consumer products.

Pebble Limited Partnership (PLP) argues that “the 80 billion pounds of copper estimated in the Pebble Deposit has the potential to meet approximately 33% of U.S. annual copper needs for many years.” Essentially, PLP argues that Pebble Mine should be allowed in part because it can improve America’s natural resource independence.

What PLP does not mention, however, is that there is a reserve of copper and other metals that is just as large, cheaper, green and more easy to access than the minerals buried beneath the profitable salmon spawning habitat of Bristol Bay. These minerals lie in American homes, recycling bins and trash cans.

Americans already recycle over 1.5 billion pounds of copper annually. Unfortunately, the EPA estimates that this copper is part of only 12.5% of the electronic waste that gets recycled annually in the US. The other 87.5% gets thrown in landfills.

By my calculations, if all electronic waste was processed properly, recycling would generate around 12.4 billion pounds of copper each year — enough to surpass the amount Pebble Mine would provide to the U.S .over its proposed 20 year lifetime — in just over 6 years.

Moreover, recycling electronics is more cost efficient and environmentally friendly than mining for new ore. Extracting metals from electronics is 13 times less costly than mining. Recycling copper expends only 10% of the energy and carbon emissions needed to process raw ore.

E-cycling also avoids the environmental destruction that would have occurred from mining for raw ore or dumping toxic metals in landfills.

Recycling more electronic waste can avoid unnecessary environmental and community harms, reduce carbon emissions and energy expenditure, and save money. Moreover, increasing the supply of metals like copper in the United States will lessen the need to mine for raw ore in Bristol Bay and weaken PLP’s principle argument in favor of the proposed Pebble Mine.

Unfortunately, Cook Inletkeeper and its partners cannot recycle all of this waste alone. We need your help to properly process electronics in Alaska and raise awareness about the importance of e-cycling to your community.

If you are passionate about saving Bristol Bay and keeping toxic metals out of your community, you can drop off your electronic waste at one of our 3 upcoming Kenai Peninsula e-cycling events.

The Homer event will occur from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on Saturday, Oct. 3 at the Homer Spenard Builders Supply. The Soldotna event will also take place from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. on Oct. 3 at the Central Peninsula Landfill. The electronic event in Seward will take place from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on Oct. 10 at the Seward Transfer Site.

To learn more about electronic recycling requirements and sites near you, visit

If you are interested in volunteering for one of these events, please email or call

907-235-4068 ext.26.

Ariel Silverman is a policy and advocacy intern at Cook Inletkeeper and will begin her junior year at Harvard College in the fall where she is studying social studies and environmental science.

More in Opinion

Alaska House District 31 candidate Kelly Cooper. (Photo by Tim Steinberg)
Candidate Point of View: Kelly Cooper

I want to take a moment and set aside all the noise… Continue reading

Rep. Sarah Vance (R-Homer) poses for a photo on June 12, 2020, in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Hannah Vance)
Candidate Point of View: Sarah Vance

Dear Friends, Election Day is almost here. Buttons, flags, road signs, flyers,… Continue reading

Michael O'Meara's cartoon for the Oct. 22, 2020, issue.
Letters to the Editor

Thoughts from readers like you

Dr. Anne Zink, Alaska Chief Medical Officer. (Photo courtesy of Alaska Department of Health and Social Services)
Point of View: Why all Alaskans should join me in getting a flu shot this year

During pandemic, getting a flu shot is more important than ever

The Homer Foundation logo.
Point of View: Pay It Forward through educational opportunities

I spent much of my life working in universities and colleges. I… Continue reading

Michael O'Meara's cartoon for Oct. 15, 2020.
Letters to the Editor

Thoughts from readers like you

Michael O'Meara's cartoon for Oct. 8, 2020.
Letters to the Editor

Thoughts from readers like you

Hal Shepherd in an undated photo taken near Homer, Alaska. (Photo courtesy of Hal Shepherd.)
Point of View: Is sacrificing ANWR worth it?

There are alternatives to sacrificing the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge’s coastal plain

Xochitl Lopez-Ayala stands in front of the Kachemak Bay Family Planning Clinic booth at Pride 2019 on June 22, 2019, in Homer, Alaska. (Photo courtesy of Xochitl Lopez-Ayala)
Point of View: Reproductive justice is also immigrant justice

The Kachemak Bay Family Planning Clinic Board recognizes that reproductive justice is… Continue reading

Most Read