US, Canada split on halibut quotas

The International Pacific Halibut Commission annual meeting ended last week with the two countries involved, the United States and Canada, unable to come to an agreement over quota cuts suggested by IPHC staff during the interim meeting in December.

Because the two sides could not agree, something that has only happened once before in the past 94 years, catch limits adopted by the IPHC in 2017 would remain in place, according to the IPHC website.

Malcolm Milne, halibut fisherman and president of Homer-based North Pacific Fisheries Association, attended the meeting, and said there were reasons the two sides could not agree.

“Both countries put forth numbers that they would each manage to domestically, instead of through the treaty organization, so they are going to take cuts, just take whatever cuts they want, because together they couldn’t come up with enough cuts to come to an agreement,” he said.

He added that what he saw was that the Canadians would not come far enough down; they wanted more pounds taken out of Alaska, Area 3A, and other areas.

“They wouldn’t bring their number close enough to the recommendation to be sufficient for the Americans.”

Milne added that the coast-wide survey, from Oregon to the Bering Sea, was really poor.

“There was a real dip in the stock, in the amount that we can harvest,” he said.

He said he went to the meeting with an open mind, but the big take-away was that two pieces of data showed that the Bering Sea and Gulf of Alaska trawl surveys both were markedly down in numbers of halibut and weight of halibut, which followed what the setline surveys showed.

“It made it scary,” Milne said.

He said the weight per unit of effort in Canadian waters in 2017 was down 23 percent, and the number per unit of effort was down 39 percent.

The big question is who decides, and how, the quotas are decided for the upcoming season.

Milne said both the Canadian and U.S. sides will put their numbers up, and that was the number they would manage to.

Because there is little or no precedence for this situation, it leaves up in the air when the halibut season will open, let alone what the quota will be.

“I am hoping that both the U.S. and Canada will eventually agree to follow the harvest advice from the IPHC and go with the science,” Milne said.

Cristy Fry can be reached at realist468@gmail.com.

More in Opinion

Willy Dunne is a member of the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly. (Courtesy photo)
Point of View: Vote By Mail makes it easy to vote and hard to cheat

Voting is the most important responsibility we have to ensure a government… Continue reading

Point of View: Foreign exchange experience leads to a more open mind

Bonjour ! Or, in English, hello. Sitting in my garden, during this… Continue reading

Letters to the Editor

Thank you, Mr. Hooker I followed my third grade teacher to Homer.… Continue reading

Point of View: Oil taxes, what oil taxes?

Five years ago, through Senate Bill 21 (SB21), Alaskans were asked to… Continue reading

Point of View: COVID-19 harms children in seen and unseen ways

COVID-19 harms children in seen and unseen ways In this historic pandemic… Continue reading

Letters to the Editor

Community support We’ve all been missing Gary during these stressful months from… Continue reading

Point of View: Homer’s Beluga Slough — A special sandhill crane nesting and viewing area

In the heart of downtown Homer, Alaska, just below the Sterling Highway… Continue reading

Letters to the Editor

Masks also stifle unkind words To the gentleman at the Homer Post… Continue reading

Point of View: Big and small, UA campuses need our support in the recall of governor

“I wonder what the Kachemak Bay Campus will become.”

Most Read