Local men found guilty of illegal commercial fishing in Dogfish Bay

Four men from Homer and Anchor Point charged with illegal commercial fishing last year will receive fines and probation,

Eric Winslow, 63, Paul Roth, 36, and Mark Roth, 66, all of Homer, and Robert Roth, 40, of Anchor Point, were all charged last year by Alaska Wildlife Troopers with various crimes relating to illegally driving salmon from waters closed to commercial fishing into open waters, and then harvesting them in Dogfish Bay (also called Koyuktolik Bay). Altogether, 33,328 pounds of salmon were taken.

“The boats went in there, they found out there was a lot of fish in that area, and four boats worked together to push these fish into a ball, and push that fish toward a set,” Rex Leath, a captain with the Alaska Wildlife Troopers, said of the incident last year.

All four men were found guilty on May 29, according to an Alaska Wildlife Trooper online dispatch report. Homer District Court Judge Margaret Murphy found Mark Roth guilty of driving salmon from closed waters, and failure to provide information to a fish transporter. He will be fined $11,000 with $7,500 suspended, and was given one year of probation, according to the dispatch. Paul Roth was found guilty of commercial fishing in closed waters, and failure to provide information to a fish transporter. His fine is $4,000 with $2,000 suspended, and he also got one year of probation.

Robert Roth was found guilty of failing to obtain a fish transporter permit, failure to complete fish tickets, and unlawful possession of fish. His sentence is a $4,000 fine with $2,500 suspended and one year probation.

Winslow was found guilty of driving salmon from closed waters, failure to provide information to a fish transporter, and failure to display vessel license. His punishment is an $11,200 fine with $7500 suspended and one year probation.

Ten thousand pounds of salmon were forfeited to the state after the incident, according to the dispatch report. Robert Roth was given 22,000 pounds of fish back that were determined to not be illegal, he said Thursday.

Troopers wrote that during sentencing, Murphy emphasized that her goals were to rehabilitate the men and deter similar crimes in the future.

“It’s important that everyone understands that driving of salmon and fishing in closed waters cannot stand,” troopers wrote.

Reach Megan Pacer at mpacer@homernews.com. This article was updated on June 6 with additional information.

More in News

Murkowski: ‘Do what’s good for Alaska’

Alaska U.S. Senator tells Legislature to work together.

Bill Roth | Anchorage Daily News
                                Protesters unfurl a banner as Gov. Mike Dunleavy speaks during a roadshow with Americans for Prosperity in 49th State Brewing Company in Anchorage on March 26.
Dunleavy recall opponents plan to drop court fight

Opponents will attempt to sway the possible recall election.

Members of the Alaska Board of Fisheries meet for the Upper Cook Inlet Finfish Meeting at the William A. Egan Convention Center in Anchorage, Alaska, on Feb. 11, 2020. (Photo by Brian Mazurek/Peninsula Clarion)
Board hikes Kenai River king salmon escapement goal

Proposal 104 was adopted by a vote of 5-2 on Friday.

Seawatch: Russian seafood embargo hurts Alaska fishing

While the U.S. trade war with China gets most of the headlines,… Continue reading

A map of the Upper Cook Inlet Drift Gill Net Management Area. (Courtesy Alaska Department of Fish and Game)
Board of Fish tightens central district drift net restrictions

The move is an effort to strengthen Susitna salmon returns.

Teresa Jacobson Gregory presents a visual illustration of the proposed gravel pit extension and the impacts it may have on residents and the surrounding state recreation area at the Anchor Point Advisory Planning Commission Meeting on Thursday, Feb. 13, 2020, at the Anchor Point Senior Center in Anchor Point, Alaska. (Photo by Delcenia Cosman)
Anchor Point advisory group recommends gravel pit expansion

No seat remained empty at the Anchor Point Senior Center last Thursday,… Continue reading

Center for Alaskan Coastal Studies becomes steward of Inspiration Ridge Preserve

Magnificent viewscapes and tranquil soundscapes surround the nearly 693-acres of Homer’s Inspiration… Continue reading

Family holds community conversation on missing daughter

As part of continued public awareness about the search for a missing… Continue reading

Homer area school announcements

Homer High School Friday — Basketball vs Redington: JV girls play at… Continue reading

Most Read