The Department of Health and Social Services, its headquarters seen here in Juneau on Monday, March 8, 2021, could be split into two departments by an executive order from the governor. However, some lawmakers have raised concern about the legality of the order, saying it could lead to costly litigation. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire)

The Department of Health and Social Services, its headquarters seen here in Juneau on Monday, March 8, 2021, could be split into two departments by an executive order from the governor. However, some lawmakers have raised concern about the legality of the order, saying it could lead to costly litigation. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire)

Lawmakers question whether proposed department split is legal

Governor maintains executive order is within his powers, others are less sure.

Lawmakers are questioning the legality of Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s use of an executive order to split the Department of Health and Social Services, saying the move would open the state to costly litigation.

At a House Health and Social Services Committee meeting Saturday, lawmakers reviewed a letter from the Legislative Legal Division outlining dozens of instances in which the executive order made substantive changes to existing law, something not allowed by executive order.

Many groups — notably tribal health care groups — have voiced opposition to the split, but in an interview Monday, Sen. Bill Wielechowski, D-Anchorage, said regardless of the intended effects of the split, the executive order being used to accomplish it is a violation of the state constitution.

“The constitution gives the governor the right to reorganize departments; however, that does not give the governor carte blanche to enact substantive law and that is what he’s doing,” Wielechowski said. “It’s written like a piece of legislation. There are at least 36 different substantive changes that our legislative attorneys have identified.”

Big changes

Wielechowski said his argument was not necessarily against splitting the state’s largest department, but against the way the governor was choosing to do it. He pointed to the legal memo which says proposed changes such as preventing registered nurses from pronouncing the death of a patient at an Alaska pioneers’ home or Alaska veterans home and adding board members to several commissions constitute substantive changes to existing law.

[Health department split would hurt Alaska Natives, leaders say]

“It appears that this executive order would impermissibly create substantive changes to existing law. However, this is a lengthy, complex, and dense executive order and it is possible that additional legal questions and issues may exist,” states the memo, written by Andrew Dunmire, legislative counsel for the Legislative Legal Division.

The governor’s office counters the proposed changes fall well within the purview of a governor’s executive order, and provide examples of other orders that included substantive changes. A Feb. 24 memo from the acting Attorney General Treg Taylor to the Senate Finance Committee notes a 2003 order under former Gov. Frank Murkowski that reorganized DHSS, including moving the Division of Senior Services and the Alaska Pioneer Homes from the Department of Administration to DHSS.

“Gov. Dunleavy is simply exercising his authority to improve the level of services provided by the department through a reorganization,” Dunleavy spokesperson Jeff Turner said in an email.

Litigation lurking

As to the line between substantive changes and lesser ones, Dunmire told lawmakers there was a lot of gray area and his memo tried to detail that. Dunmire cited the issue with nurses at the pioneers’ homes as a substantial change, saying the proposal would substantively alter their duties.

Those are the kinds of changes that could lead to litigation, Weleichowski said. Changes to the duties of public employees could lead to legal challenge from unions, he said, who were just one of many groups who might bring litigation.

The governor introduced his proposal late last year, and the suggestion was met with immediate opposition from health care and tribal groups. The executive order was introduced into the Legislature on Jan. 25, and lawmakers have 60 days to disapprove. If they fail to act by March 24, the order automatically goes into effect.

The changes in the order, including splitting DHSS into the Department of Health and the Department of Family and Community Services, would be implemented July 1, 2021, according to the governor’s office.

A special concurrent resolution has already been drafted to disapprove of the order, and needs only a simple majority of a joint session of the Legislature to pass. However, with current health mitigation rules in place, lawmakers have yet to find a way to hold a joint session.

But Weleichowski said he was optimistic the memo would raise a few eyebrows and motivate lawmakers to act.

“The Legislature is able to move very quickly when it wants to,” he said.

Contact reporter Peter Segall at psegall@juneauempire.com.

Follow him on Twitter at @SegallJnuEmpire.

More in News

Christie Hill prepares to play “Taps” during the 9/11 memorial service on Saturday. (Photo by Sarah Knapp/Homer News)
Homer honors lives lost during 9/11

The Homer-Kachemak Bay Rotary held a Sept. 11 memorial ceremony at the… Continue reading

Judith Eckert
COVID-19 patient says monoclonal antibody infusion saved her life

Antibody infusions highly effective in reducing risk of hospitalization, according to FDA trial ..

A sign flashing “Keep COVID down” also offers information on where to get testing and vaccines on Thursday, Sept. 2, 2021, on the Homer Spit in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
SPH holding steady in COVID-19 surge

Despite hospital crisis in Anchorage, Homer’s hospital not impacted, spokesperson tells Homer City Council.

Brie Drummond speaks in support of mask mandates on Monday, Sept. 13, for the Kenai Peninsula School Board meeting at Homer High School in Homer, Alaska. During a work session before the meeting, the district presented revisions to its COVID-19 mitigation protocols. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
School district revises COVID-19 mitigation plans

The revisions come as COVID-19 cases continue to surge in Alaska and on the Kenai Peninsula.

A protester stands outside the George A. Navarre Borough Admin building in Soldotna on Tuesday, Sept. 14, 2021. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
Parents square off over masks at school board meeting

Some parents said they will keep their kids home if masks are required, while others say they’ll keep their kids home if masks aren’t required.

.
Borough School Board election

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

.
Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly election

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

.
Homer City Council election

On Tuesday, Oct. 5, elections will be held for Homer City Council,… Continue reading

Janie Leask, a Homer resident, spoke in support of the new multi-use community center during Monday night’s city council meeting, stating the need for community recreation is vital.
Council moves forward with HERC plans

After years of discussions and planning, the Homer City Council is quickly… Continue reading

Most Read