The Alaska House votes on whether to prepare for a lawsuit against Gov. Mike Dunleavy about forward funding education in the next fiscal year. (Alex McCarthy | Juneau Empire)

The Alaska House votes on whether to prepare for a lawsuit against Gov. Mike Dunleavy about forward funding education in the next fiscal year. (Alex McCarthy | Juneau Empire)

Lawsuit pits role of Legislature against power of governor

Suit over forward funding would tackle issue of separation of powers, strength of governor

The Alaska Legislature is preparing to sue the governor.

Both the House and Senate voted Tuesday to authorize the Alaska Legislative Council to sue Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s administration if the administration refuses to provide funding for public schools that last year’s Legislature guaranteed. The showdown has been simmering for most of this year’s legislative session, overshadowed by huge proposed budget cuts, wildly differing views on the Permanent Fund Dividend and clashes over crime legislation.

The suit — which has not been filed — has already posed questions to lawmakers and the governor of how the Legislature and governor work together to create the budget, and who has the upper hand in the process.

Last year’s Legislature approved guaranteeing funding for public schools for the fiscal year starting July 1, 2019, in an effort to provide schools with financial stability so they wouldn’t have to issue layoffs. The Department of Law reviewed the bill and did not identify a constitutional issue, according to a Department of Law memo dated May 1, 2018.

“Although not common, it is permissible for the Legislature to include in a budget bill appropriations for future fiscal years,” said the memo, written by then-Attorney General Jahna Lindemuth. “These appropriations do not bind a future Legislature because a future Legislature can always amend, reappropriate, or repeal the future appropriations.”

Alaska Attorney General Kevin Clarkson has issued a letter in April and a formal opinion earlier this month expressing that he believes forward funding is unconstitutional because he sees this as a current Legislature making decisions for a future Legislature, though that’s not how his predecessor saw it.

Clarkson’s opinion, filed May 8, was also focused on preserving the power of the governor, especially when it comes to a line-item veto. He wrote that forward funding not only ties the hands of lawmakers, but also of the governor’s.

Clarkson cited multiple court cases that accentuate the power of Alaska’s executive branch. In 1977’s Thomas v. Rosen, Clarkson cited the Alaska Supreme Court ruling that the governor’s veto power was guaranteed by the drafters of the state’s constitution because they wanted a governor to have “a strong control on the purse strings of the state.”

Sen. Gary Stevens, R-Kodiak, is the chair of the Legislative Council and said in a press conference Tuesday that he believes the main issue here is about the separation of powers.

“It’s crucial to me, having been in the Legislature 19 years, that we not give away, willy-nilly, the authority and the responsibility of the Legislature,” Stevens said. “It is our responsibility to pass budgets, it is our responsibility to pass laws. It is the governor’s responsibility, the administration’s responsibility to execute those laws that we pass and those budgets that we pass.”

[Here’s what crime bill means for Dunleavy’s ‘war on criminals’]

Legislators and Dunleavy both said in press conferences Tuesday that funding for schools this year is still likely to come through, as they believe a court would figure out a way to issue a ruling that would allow schools to be funded even during a lawsuit. Dunleavy said that he could withhold the extra $30 million that last year’s Legislature approved, in effect spurring the Legislature to file the suit.

“We’d just like to get that off the table and then clarify, potentially holding back on some of the funding, the $30 million just to initiate a suit,” Dunleavy said, “almost a friendly suit, just so we can get clarification when we’re moving forward on things.”

Gov. Mike Dunleavy speaks with his cabinet members at the Capitol on Tuesday, Jan. 8, 2019. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

Gov. Mike Dunleavy speaks with his cabinet members at the Capitol on Tuesday, Jan. 8, 2019. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

This would be the second time in five years that the Alaska Legislature sued a sitting governor. In 2015, the Legislature filed a lawsuit against then-Gov. Bill Walker, asserting that his expansion of Medicaid was unconstitutional. A judge threw that lawsuit out, saying the administration was within the law in expanding Medicaid because it followed the federal text of the Affordable Care Act allowing for the expansion of Medicaid.

Legislators voted to spend as much as $450,000 from the state’s budget to pursue that lawsuit, according to reports at the time. Current lawmakers did not discuss cost estimates Tuesday.

The decision to prepare for the lawsuit passed the House 23-14, and passed the Senate 14-4. House Minority Leader Lance Pruitt spoke against it on the floor, asserting that he thought pursuing this would be a waste of money.

Dunleavy said Tuesday that he won’t veto education funding, and said he just wants to establish the groundwork for whether a Legislature can guarantee funding in future years and how far in advance the Legislature can guarantee funding. Dunleavy rattled off a list of questions during Tuesday’s press conference, asking where this stops if a Legislature can fund something a year ahead of time.

“If you can fund in the manner that the Legislature’s claiming it can fund,” Dunleavy said, “why not fund everything that way?”


• Contact reporter Alex McCarthy at amccarthy@juneauempire.com. Follow him on Twitter at @akmccarthy.


The Alaska Senate votes on whether to prepare for a lawsuit against Gov. Mike Dunleavy about forward funding education in the next fiscal year. (Alex McCarthy | Juneau Empire)

The Alaska Senate votes on whether to prepare for a lawsuit against Gov. Mike Dunleavy about forward funding education in the next fiscal year. (Alex McCarthy | Juneau Empire)

Members of the Alaska Legislature’s Legislative Council prepare to speak to media members about preparing for a lawsuit against the governor’s administration over the future of education funding at the Alaska State Capitol on Tuesday, May 28, 2019. (Alex McCarthy | Juneau Empire)

Members of the Alaska Legislature’s Legislative Council prepare to speak to media members about preparing for a lawsuit against the governor’s administration over the future of education funding at the Alaska State Capitol on Tuesday, May 28, 2019. (Alex McCarthy | Juneau Empire)

More in News

Photo by Brian Mazurek/Peninsula Clarion 
                                The entrance to the Kenai Peninsula Borough building in Soldotna is seen here on June 1.
Application period for borough relief funds begins Monday

Borough residents can apply for these grants July 13 through July 24.

Homer Farmers Market: Farmers offer stability in times of uncertainty

In a time of uncertainty, it certainly is nice to know where… Continue reading

Hospital adds new COVID-19 rooms

An increase last month in positive COVID-19 cases on the lower Kenai… Continue reading

Peonies cover a table, ready to receive people at a field to vase dinner tour hosted by Certified American Grown Flowers on Saturday, July 29, 2017 at Scenic Place Peonies in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Homer Peony Celebration begins this week

With many large or indoor events canceled this year due to the… Continue reading

COVID-19. (Image courtesy the CDC)
9 new COVID-19 cases on the Kenai Peninsula

The central Kenai Peninsula saw growth in the number of new COVID-19… Continue reading

The Betty J. Glick Assembly Chambers in Soldotna, Alaska. (Peninsula Clarion file photo)
Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly overrides mayoral veto of hybrid election system ordinance

Members of the Kenai Peninsula Borough assembly voted to override a mayoral… Continue reading

Independence Day parade organized after official event gets canceled

The continued spread of COVID-19 across Alaska prompted many official organizations and… Continue reading

A young volunteer chases three piglets named Mary Hamkins, Petunia and Sir Oinks-a-lot through a race during the pig races at the Kenai Peninsula Fair on Friday, Aug. 16, 2019 at the Kenai Peninsula Fairgrounds in Ninilchik, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Kenai Peninsula Fair canceled this year

Cotton candy, carnival rides and racing pigs will have to wait for… Continue reading

Members of the Homer City Council interview candidate Rob Dumouchel for the job of city manager on Wednesday, July 1, 2020 via Zoom in Homer, Alaska. Top row from left to right: Council member Joey Evensen, Mayor Ken Castner, Council member Heath Smith. Middle row from left to right: Council members Donna Aderhold, Rachel Lord and Storm Hansen-Cavasos. Bottom row from left to right: Candidate Rob Dumouchel and Council member Caroline Venuti.
Council offers city manager job to California candidate

The Homer City Council voted last week to offer the job of… Continue reading

Most Read