Producers say Senate tax bill a big step, but tweaks needed to make Alaska competitive

JUNEAU — Major North Slope producers say legislators are making big strides so far in making Alaska more competitive for new oil investment, but Senate Bill 21, which passed the Senate narrowly March 20, still needs some changes to make the state really attractive.

The tax rate is too high, at 35 percent of net profits, and a “Gross Revenue Exclusion” feature that is a proposed incentive for new oil to be developed in producing fields is too vague and needs more precise wording, the companies told the House Resources Committee in hearings March 26.

Dan Seckers, ExxonMobil’s Alaska tax manager, said he’d like to see Alaska position itself to be more attractive against its competitors to overcome high costs and regulatory barriers that confront Alaska oil development.

“You’ve made significant progress in making Alaska more competitive globally just by eliminating ‘progressivity’ (a formula in the tax that drives up tax rates). If you do nothing else, that is significant,” Seckers said. “We’re bullish on Alaska. We want to invest here. You can make Alaska more competitive, but you need to also make it attractive,” to overcome high costs.

The bill as passed by the Senate does put Alaska “in the middle of the pack” among oil producing regions competing for industry investment, but at the top end of that tier, according to modeling by ConocoPhillips that was presented to the House committee by Bob Heinrich, the company’s vice president for finance, and Scott Jepsen, vice president for external affairs.

ConocoPhillips’ modeling shows the “total government take” under the current oil production tax, called ACES, at more than 75 percent of net profits from production. The version of SB 21 passed by the Senate would lower that to about 65 percent, according to the modeling data presented to the House committee.

If the base tax rate was lowered to 30 percent, a rate considered in the Senate but then raised to 35 percent in the bill finally passed by that body, the government take would be about 62 percent.

That level would position Alaska more in line with other producing nations like Australia, or the Lower 48, the data indicated. In its presentation ConocoPhillips overlaid its data on comparisons of fiscal systems developed by PFC Energy, a consulting firm hired by the Legislature.

Consultants to the Legislature, such as Roger Marks, a former state petroleum economist, have suggested using total government take as a better overall way of comparing fiscal systems than other ways of measuring the effect under tax systems of different nations, such as Internal Rate of Return or Net Present Value of particular projects.

Government take includes all taxes, state and federal, as well as royalty to landowners.

None of the companies appearing before House Resources March 26 would comment on what an appropriate base tax rate might be. The current tax law, ACES, has it set at 25 percent, although the progressivity formula increases the rate as oil prices increase.

 Another concern voiced by ConocoPhillips is that SB 21 still retains elements that make it regressive in terms of total tax burden, meaning that the tax burden climbs in lower oil price ranges.

 Heinrich told the committee that his company encourages legislators to make the tax effect generally level across all ranges of oil prices, and SB 21 generally achieves that, at about 34 percent producer share of profits (or 66 percent to the state and federal governments), until prices drop to about $92 per barrel.

 Below that the current ACES tax actually gives the companies more share of profits because of a 20 percent capital investment tax credit in the current law. This has a major effect on company returns at lower prices. It is taken out of SB 21, however, and replaced by a $5-per-barrel production tax credit. That $5-per-barrel credit doesn’t do enough to offset the loss of the capital investment credit, however, Heinrich said.

 At about $60 per barrel prices a minimum gross severance tax that is in both the current ACES law and SB 21 would kick in, driving the industry return down sharply to about 24 percent share of profits (76 percent to the state) if oil prices were to drop to just over $50 per barrel.

 

Tim Bradner can be reached at tim.bradner@alaskajournal.com.

 

More in News

Dollynda Phelps discusses current issues in the cannabis industry with local business owners on Wednesday, Sept. 12, 2018, in Kenai, Alaska. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)
Cannabis industry meeting raises concerns over Alcohol and Marijuana Control Office

Cannabis cultivators, retailers and consumers squeezed into a small Kenai living room… Continue reading

The wall of the Red Chris tailings pond is a little less than 350 feet, or about the height of a 35-story building. It follows the same design as the Mount Polley tailings dam, which broke in 2014, sending 24 million cubic meters of toxic mine tailings into the Fraser River watershed. It is designed, however, to hold 305 million cubic meters of mine waste — seven times more than Mount Polley. Both mines are owned by Imperial Metals. (Courtesy Photo | Garth Lenz via Salmon State)
Transboundary mine faces $200-million cash crunch

With a strike, falling copper prices and more than $554-million ($723 million… Continue reading

Niko Mogar is shown in a June 2018 booking photo. (Photo provided, Homer Police)
Police arrest Homer area thief on new counts

A man charged last month with burglary and vehicle theft faces new… Continue reading

Homer area residents listen to the Tuesday, Sept. 18, 2018 Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly meeting at Homer City Hall in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Residents talk Kachemak Selo school at assembly

While no major action was taken at Tuesday’s Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly… Continue reading

Ken Castner III answers a question at a city council and mayoral candidate forum Tuesday, Sept. 11, 2018 at Alice’s Champagne Palace in Homer, Alaska. Castner is running for Homer mayor. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Castner running for mayor to promote unity

Although Ken Castner has served on numerous city commissions, committees and task… Continue reading

Homer area school announcements

Homer High School Friday — Homecoming football game against Seward High School… Continue reading

David Lewis, a former member of the Homer City Council, makes his final remarks during his last meeting as a council member Monday, Oct. 9, 2017 in Cowles Council Chambers in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Lewis takes second try at Homer mayor

Veteran Homer City Council member David Lewis will take another run for… Continue reading

Borough elections 2018: What you need to know

In between the August primary election and the November general election, Homer… Continue reading

Supreme Court finds Griswold due process rights violated

Editor’s note: This story has been updated to include a comment from… Continue reading

Most Read