Seawatch: Alaska Supreme Court hears challenge to fish tax

Seawatch: Alaska Supreme Court hears challenge to fish tax

If fish landing tax is overturned, ports could lose millions

Alaska’s Supreme Court heard arguments last week about the legality of a raw fish tax that has pumped at least $25 million into coastal communities over the just the past five years, according to KUCB Public Radio in Unalaska.

A Washington state catcher/processor filed suit to challenge the Fisheries Resource Landing Tax that has been in place since the 1990s and taxes seafood caught by factory trawlers and floating processors.

Even though the fish is caught outside the 3-mile line in what’s considered federal waters, it’s often brought to Alaska fishing ports before loaded on cargo vessels and shipped overseas.

But seafood company Fisherman’s Finest has challenged the tax in court, arguing it violates a pair of provisions of the U.S. Constitution that restricts coastal states from imposing tariffs or duties on goods brought in and out of a state.

Attorney Jim Torgerson told the Court that the U.S. Supreme Court wrote in 1996, “it has never upheld a state tax assessed directly on goods in import or export transit.”

“Yet the state is here today, asking this court to uphold a state tax assessed directly on goods in export transit,” he told the court.

Washington-based Fisherman’s Finest won a lower-court decision last year saying the fish tax is unconstitutional. But the state of Alaska has appealed.

Assistant Attorney General Laura Fox told the justices that the framers of the U.S. Constitution weren’t interested in giving some taxpayers preferential treatment.

“Catcher/processor operations take advantage of Alaska to further their business and Alaska’s landing tax merely requires them to pay their fair share for doing business in Alaska like other businesses do,” she said.

The tax brought in nearly $42 million over the past four years, more than half of which was shared with Alaska fishing ports.

If it is struck down, it would hit especially hard in Unalaska/Dutch Harbor, homeport of the lucrative pollock fishery, providing $4.6 million in 2019 alone.

“I think they should pay,” Unalaska’s vice mayor Dennis Robinson told KUBC on Wednesday. “They use our services to to be able to get their product to market.”

Robinson added if the tax is struck down, the Unalaska could establish its own excise tax. But that wouldn’t do much for the rest of the state.

“We would like to see, as a city, we’d like to see that tax remain in effect,” he said. “And not only for our own interest, but for the interests of the state of Alaska.”

The justices asked only a few questions. It’s not clear when they’ll rule whether Alaska’s Fisheries Resource Landing Tax is legal under the U.S. Constitution.

Cristy Fry can be reached at realist468@gmail.com

More in News

The sign in front of the Homer Electric Association building in Kenai, Alaska as seen on April 1, 2020. (Photo by Brian Mazurek/Peninsula Clarion)
Candidate nomination deadline for HEA election approaches

Elections for the Homer Electric Association Board of Directors are coming up,… Continue reading

Commercial fishing and other boats are moored in the Homer Harbor in this file photo. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Seawatch: International Pacific Halibut Commission studying COVID-19 impacts on fishermen

Three surveys will look at financial impacts before and during the pandemic

The Pfizer vaccine for COVID-19 shortly after it arrived at the South Peninsula Hospital on Wednesday, Dec. 16, 2020 in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
State opens next vaccination tier

More than 23% of peninsula residents have gotten first vaccine dose

Alaska state Sen. Lora Reinbold, an Eagle River Republican, holds a copy of the Alaska Constitution during a committee hearing on Wednesday, Jan. 27, 2021, in Juneau, Alaska. Gov. Mike Dunleavy, a Republican, sent Reinbold a letter on Feb. 18, 2021, saying she has used her position to “misrepresent” the state’s COVID-19 response. Reinbold said the letter was “full of baseless accusations and complaints.” (AP Photo / Becky Bohrer)
Dunleavy says Reinbold misrepresents virus response

Dunleavy said his administration will no longer participate in hearings led by Sen. Lora Reinbold

Homer News file photo
Homer High School.
School announcements

School district risk level update and upcoming events

This undated photo shows a section of Deep Creek near Ninilchik, Alalska recently acquired by the Alaska Department of Fish and Game with the assistance of the Kachemak Heritage Land Trust to protect hunting and fishing in the area. (Photo courtesy of Kachemak Heritage Land Trust)
State, feds and land trust work together to acquire 93.5 acres for conservation

Oil spill trust fund used to buy fish habitat on valuable salmon stream

The entrance to the Homer Electric Association office is seen here in Kenai, Alaska on May 7, 2020. (Photo by Brian Mazurek/Peninsula Clarion)
HEA work at Stonehocker Creek presents challenges

HEA remediation work across the bay continues

Ben Dickson, November winner of the Homer Flex Phoenix Award. (Photo courtesy Beth Schneider/Homer Flex School)
November Homer Flex award winner announced

The November winner of the monthly student award given out by Homer… Continue reading

This undated map shows three wildlife enhancement projects on the southern Kenai Peninsula, Alaska, planned or done by the Alaska Department of Fish and Game. (Map courtesy of Alaska Department of Fish and Game)
Three projects on southern Kenai Peninsula aim to benefit moose habitat

Cut willow bushes will regenerate into higher protein browse for moose

Most Read